Classic Pies

Berry (WF or V option)


 French Apple 

Blueberry (WF or V option)

Cherry (WF or V option)

Streusel Cherry

Mixed Berry (WF or V option) (seasonal)

 Peach (WF or V option) (seasonal)

Streusel Peach (seasonal)

 Pumpkin (WF option) 

Pecan (WF option)


Wheat-Free and/or Vegan preference must be specifically requested when placing order. Wheat Free pie crust contains egg.  Our products may contain pit or nutshell fragments.

Cream Pies

Chocolate Cream

Peanut Butter

Lemon Berry (March - September)

Key Lime (March - September)

Coconut Cream

Elderflower (March - September)

Strawberry Lemonade (Memorial Day - Labor Day)

Irish Cream (March)

Pumpkin (October - December)

Peppermint Cookies & Cream (December)

Eggnog (Decemberl)

Buttery Pie Pockets

handheld happiness


Apple (seasonal)

Peach (seasonal)

(limited quantities, no pre-orders)

Pie Pocket

Our products may contain pit or nutshell fragments

© 2003 - 2020 Icing on the Cake, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Yelp - White Circle